Deadly Deception: The Chilling Cyanide Poisoning Plot in Rock County, Wisconsin
- 608areascanner
- 2 days ago
- 2 min read
Updated: 16 hours ago

The Rock County Cyanide Poisoning Plot: A Chilling Tale of Betrayal and Malice
In a case that has stunned southern Wisconsin, a former Princeton graduate and his girlfriend stand accused of orchestrating a series of poisonings targeting women he had briefly dated. The plot, which involved deadly substances like cyanide, thallium, and abrin, has left the community in disbelief and prompted a massive law enforcement response.
The Alleged Plot Unfolds
Paul VanDuyne Jr., a 43-year-old mechanical engineer, and Andrea Whitaker, 41, a pharmacology student, are accused of conspiring to poison at least two women VanDuyne had met through dating apps. The first victim, a woman from Middleton, reported that her car had been broken into twice. On both occasions, she found that her water bottle had been tampered with, leading her to believe someone had poisoned it. Subsequent testing confirmed the presence of cyanide in the bottle
The second victim, from Rock County, experienced a more severe ordeal. She discovered a powdery substance in her car and drank from a water bottle, leading to hospitalization. Authorities allege that VanDuyne and Whitaker had placed cyanide and thallium in her water bottle and had also tampered with her car's air vents, introducing abrin, a toxic plant protein
The Investigation and Arrests
The investigation began in April when the Middleton victim reported her suspicions to the police. Authorities linked the tampered water bottle to VanDuyne through forensic analysis. As the investigation progressed, a similar case emerged in Rock County, leading to a joint effort between local and state law enforcement agencies.
In June, VanDuyne was arrested after he was observed placing a trail camera near one of the victims' homes. Whitaker was apprehended the following day when she entered VanDuyne's residence with a laptop and a garbage bag full of evidence
Legal Proceedings and Charges
Both VanDuyne and Whitaker have been charged with multiple offenses, including attempted first-degree intentional homicide, stalking, and harboring a felon. In Rock County, Whitaker's bond was set at $15 million, while VanDuyne's bond in Dane County was set at $10 million
The case has garnered national attention due to the severity of the charges and the involvement of dangerous toxins. Investigators discovered vials, rosary peas, and a seed grinder at the suspects' residence, indicating a premeditated effort to manufacture poisons New York Post.
Community Impact and Ongoing Developments
The victims have expressed their fear and trauma resulting from the alleged poisonings. One victim stated, "I no longer feel safe, not at home, not out in the community. I am scared for myself. I am scared for my two children. I cannot sleep soundly"
As the legal proceedings continue, the community remains on edge, grappling with the implications of such a calculated and malicious scheme. The case serves as a stark reminder of the potential dangers lurking in everyday interactions and the importance of vigilance and trust in personal relationships.
For more detailed coverage and updates on this case, you can refer to the following sources:
Comments